How To Choose SEO Agency? Question to Ask Before You Sign
Ask an SEO agency to explain the problem, work, dependencies and measurement limitations in writing. Who will implement changes, and who owns the accounts? Ask for evidence to evaluate the proposal. A long list of vague deliverables does not help.
In this guide
- Request diagnosis based on your website problem
- Check what is proved from evidence
- Clarify ownership and implementation
- Find measurement you can act on
Request diagnosis based on your website problem
In ABDM's SEO proposal, it should link your observed page or campaign problem with a specific proposed change. Like which page or customer stage have the problem, what evidence is used for diagnosis, and how do we check your recommendation. Generic list of technical SEO / content / links do not help you prioritize budget.
Before give access, clarify purpose and level of access. Maybe read only access for initial review is sufficient. You should be able to understand the first task of what to do in business language after the meeting. If not, ask for clarification before accepting the scope.
Check what is actually proved from evidence
Ask your SEO provider to provide you relevant evidence on starting state, completed work, comparison date, limitations. Request proof (permission to share) instead of private customer accounts. Unordered chart does not prove what caused the improvement without date, scope and attribution.
Don't just make up similar case when you don't have experience in their industry. Separate proven outcome from proposed method. See also Google's guidelines for hiring SEO provider. It's useful to ask some questions and cautions to apply your operation requirements.
Clarify ownership and implementation
You should have very clear idea about your business domain, hosting, Google analytics, search console and business profile ownership and access. Document how access / approval / account handling will work after the end of engagement. Ask if it includes implementation? Who will get the tasks for developer? Who will check on the deployed changes?
SEO provider may recommend a good change, but it's useless if they cannot implement it without your team. This should be discussed before sign the contract, not after delayed report. Grant access to accounts by proper permissions, not by sharing passwords. You should always have workable control of your properties for your business.
Find measurement you can act on
For ABDM, what would be the project review report like? For example, live changes, outstanding dependencies, observed results. A useful review should separate recommendation, approved task, deployed change, observed result. Also, what does not work, what can not be measured yet.
Discuss in advance how feedback about unsuitable enquiry will affect your plan. And who will attend the decision meetings. Check our lead measurement guide for helping define outcome. Report length alone is not the judgement. A short review clear next decision is better than long report of unexplained rankings.
Compare your options
| Ask This | What Useful Answer Should Be | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Why do this task first? | Page evidence and consequence | Same package for everyone |
| Who will implement it? | Named owner and approval | Present as completed work with recommendation |
| What will we measure? | Relevant enquiry and limitation | Rankings alone |
| What happens when engagement end? | Handover access and asset | Not clear account control |
Actionable checklist
- Compare same brief for all proposals
- Request for diagnosis evidence of page
- Check allowed example and limitation
- Clarify implementation responsibilities
- Keep main accounts ownership with your business
- Document reporting, approval and exit terms
Related guides or service
- Main SEO guide for business owner
- Compare scope and budget
- Understand implementation stages
- Discuss Your Project
Research method
This question list helps you to check if the proposal provides clear diagnosis, evidence, delivery responsibilities and account access. You can check Google guideline for hiring SEO provider for independent reference. It's buyer checklist. Not agency ranking / certification. So carefully evaluate actual agreement and relevant evidence for choosing provider.
Limitations
This is editorial procurement checklist. Not any agency certification. For ABDM, we need written agreement on service scope, commercial terms. We do not guarantee ranking / lead quantities / completion date.
Sources
Final decision
Select a provider you can clearly understand their thinking, work boundaries and responsibilities. It's a better base to make decision with clear scope and real evidence. Because no external provider has control over the search engine systems.
Discuss your project. Tell us about your website, service, customer decision you want to improve.
Frequently asked questions
Can we guarantee top ranking?
There is no provider who has the control over final search result. Don't ask guaranteed ranking. Ask them delivery promise. And transparent review criteria.
Specialist or wide service agency?
It depends on what work you need and coordination. Specialist can be suitable for narrow problem. Wider team may help coordinate dependencies (content / development / ad). This should depend on actual scope, not just name only.
What should I send to ABDM before discuss?
Let us know your website, main service, target customer, service delivery area. What do you want to improve in the business action. Do not send passwords, sensitive customer records with initial enquiry.
Editorial questions and answers
Can we guarantee top ranking?
There is no provider who has the control over final search result. Don't ask guaranteed ranking. Ask them delivery promise. And transparent review criteria.
Specialist or wide service agency?
It depends on what work you need and coordination. Specialist can be suitable for narrow problem. Wider team may help coordinate dependencies (content / development / ad). This should depend on actual scope, not just name only.
What should I send to ABDM before discuss?
Let us know your website, main service, target customer, service delivery area. What do you want to improve in the business action. Don't send passwords, private customer records for initial enquiry.