Questions for Agency evaluation

What to ask before choosing agency

When you're evaluating a proposal from an agency, look at evidence, deliverables and responsibilities. The guidance below is from ABDM. So ask about how recommendations are relevant to your website. What information you need to look into. Make sure who's going to implement changes. What's separate fees. How you'll interpret the results. If there's evidence they share from clients. Make sure you look at what work it is. Dates of comparison. Permission to share that evidence. If they just show logo or unexplained % It doesn't answer all those questions. See agency selection guide for detailed comparison.

What's the evidence for recommendation? So what page or campaign? What's the problem you noticed? And how proposed action will address that problem. Not just generic score for audit. What's impact to business. So it should be easier to evaluate the decisions from the evidence.
Illustrative avatar; not a client portrait
Evidence
ABDM guidance
Exactly what you'll deliver. So look at which pages or channels. Documents. Creative assets. For scope. Make sure what's revisions. Approvals. And implementation. So if there's anything excluded from scope. Make sure you know who's going to do it. Before you make the project depend on that.
Illustrative avatar; not a client portrait
Deliverables
ABDM guidance
How do you separate fees? So make sure separate management. Implementation. Media spend. Fees for external platforms. Compare different proposals based on work and responsibilities. Not just headline monthly fee.
Illustrative avatar; not a client portrait
Fees & Exclusions
ABDM guidance
How will you interpret the results? So make sure dated baseline. Comparable periods for reporting. And define a qualified enquiry. So it may change depending on seasonality. Or changes in tracking. Or campaigns. So you're going to get different overall results. But make sure in report. It's clear how they're limiting that. Not just saying everything's due to this activity.
Illustrative avatar; not a client portrait
Reporting
ABDM guidance
What access do you need to accounts? So ownership. And permissions. So they may need to have access to look into problem. But that doesn't mean you're giving ownership of account. Or submitting passwords in public form.
Illustrative avatar; not a client portrait
Permissions
ABDM guidance
When should you care about case study? So look at same type of problem for business. And make sure dated baseline. Documented work. And clear limitations. Not unrelated % of traffic. And just decorate the page with logo. Not proof for suitability of service.
Illustrative avatar; not a client portrait
Relevant Proof
ABDM guidance